Archive for July 8th, 2010

Commentary: Wrong track, wrong direction

Thursday, July 8th, 2010
 
 
by Dr Isaac Newton

I read Peter Richards’ article ‘Antigua Threatens Sanctions Against the United States’ on Caribarena’s online news with intense interest. I distilled that PM Spencer is expressing a certain brand of ‘righteous anger’ over the United States’ (US) refusal to settle the World Trade Organization (WTO) ruling with Antigua and Barbuda (A&B).

Dr Isaac Newton is an international leadership and change management consultant and political adviser who specialises in government and business relations, and sustainable development projects. Dr Newton works extensively in West Africa, the Caribbean and Latin America, and is a graduate of Oakwood College, Harvard, Princeton and Columbia. He has published several books on personal development and written many articles on economics, leadership, political, social, and faith-based issues

Spencer typically dwells on the egregious effect that the United States’ behavior has had on A&B’s economy. But he gives few considerations and realistic proposals of improving relations with the US. It is reasonable however, that Spencer should advocate that the US should respect voluntary codes of conduct consistent with international rules governing the WTO.

Amongst a thousand reasons, Spencer has one motivation to improve relations with the US. That is, A&B carriers the towering presence of Mount Obama—its highest peak, a tribute paid to President Obama by Spencer himself.

Overshadowed by years of failed negotiations, Spencer has arrived at a formidable impediment. He realizes that as a super power, the US is determined to protect its national interests with little regard for international monitoring and compliance verification of the WTO. The PM now is considering the option of imposing sanctions against the US.

The rational for Spencer’s decision is that the US has sustained its position through a prolonged process of sidestepping that offsets the nation’s progress, tantamount to abusing a small island state. There may be other complexities involved.

Yet, it is a discerning leader indeed who can make a wise choice between the ethics of a little axe cutting down a big tree, and the geo-politics of a M1A1 Abrams’ tank crushing a small rose.

Spencer’s decision is further compounded by a dangling political future at home. He awaits the Eastern Caribbean Court of Appeals’ decision, and within a month may be compelled to go back to the polls with the likelihood of descending into the valley of the shadow of death.

Adding more pepper to the stew, the PM is currently presiding over a deadbeat economy— which is fundamentally dictated by IMF’s dominant interests. The prevailing mood amongst a vast sector of the population suggests a general exodus. Sensing his tenure is on the brink, and that voters believe his leadership amounts to a travesty of public service, Spencer seems trapped between getting results and the dramatics of appearing tough. Folkloric wisdom cautions, “You don’t cut off your nose to fix your face.”

In this context, imposing sanctions against the US invites a yawn and a smile. It also represents a public autopsy that Spencer is unable to handle the uncertainty of his office with keen thoughtfulness. Perhaps the PM may prove naysayers wrong, but to date, he has not gotten his leadership act together fast enough to reach expected potential.

At best, sanctions against the US may evoke symbolic sympathy from Caricom as well as some members of the international community. I cannot see any benefits whatsoever, bestowed to A&B, anytime in our preferred future. A&B cannot afford to erode its hemispheric relations with and economic ties to the US.

Perhaps Spencer should consider the possibility of another attempt at soft negotiations, even if in the past, this strategy might have been met with subtle but fierce resistance. It is quite possible that the road to effective diplomacy supported by patience, fresh eyes, and a philosophy of finding common ground, can effect flourishing change.

What the PM needs right now is a strategic intelligence pathway that produces a win-win for Antigua and Barbuda and the US. But this requires possibility thinking that does not align with Spencer’s natural mode of political miscalculations.

Seen through critical lens, Spencer has become a captive to the dogma that desperate times call for desperate measures. But the pragmatics of this strategy applied to the WTO’s case, will not yield financial reward or diplomatic right-thinking. Both of these ingredients are needed for the country’s long-term prosperity.

Although I have completely given up on Spencer’s leadership credentials to turn the ship of state in the right direction, the nation needs well-practiced operational-skills to address this matter. But Spencer will have to ignore his string of advisors, whose failed ideas are now brilliantly evident in the trademark of colossal failures, intrinsic to his administration.

Mired in high-stakes politics where perceptions of eroding ethics and unfair treatment intersect to destroy democratic values and international trust, Spencer should see by some force of miraculous intervention, that evoking sanctions against the US, will not guarantee our national successes or lessen our regional challenges.

Ultimately, the PM can not afford to pretend to operate in a vacuum. Should he move towards sanctions, he will induce an aberration, far too costly for our nation to bear. Sanctions would not hurt the US. At best, influential countries, whose economies are linked to Wall Street, may frown at United States’ non-compliance posture. And nothing will happen, except that A&B will feel untold pain.

I hope Spencer will reconsider his odd temptation, and push the envelope in the pursuit of doing what is right for A&B. Or he will continue on the wrong track— heading farther in the wrong direction. (Caribnet)

 
 

Two CARICOM nationals selected for Commonwealth Eminent Persons Group

Thursday, July 8th, 2010
 
by Oscar Ramjeet

Two eminent CARICOM nationals were among ten who have been selected for the Commonwealth Eminent Persons Group.

They are Guyanese Sir Ronald Sanders, international consultant, writer and former Caribbean diplomat, and Jamaican Patricia R. Francis, an award-winning leader and business facilitator.

The announcement was made by Commonwealth Secretary General Kamalesh Sharma on Wednesday.

The other eight are from Malaysia, Pakistan, Uganda, Australia, Mozambique, United Kingdom, Canada and Kiribati.

“This distinguished Group will set out decisive recommendations on how to strengthen the Commonwealth and fulfill its potential in the 21st century,” Sharma said when he made the announcement. The Group’s work will aim to ensure that the Commonwealth remains relevant to its times and makes the best use of its networks and partnerships to do so.

At their 2009 meeting in Port of Spain, Trinidad and Tobago, Commonwealth leaders called for the “creation of an Eminent Persons Group to undertake an examination of options for return in order to bring the Commonwealth’s many institutions into a stronger and more effective framework of co-operation and partnership”

The Group is also tasked with looking at the format, frequency, and content of Commonwealth ministerial meetings.

The EPG will have its first meeting in London from 19 to 20 July 2010. The Group will present its recommendations to Commonwealth leaders at their next meeting in Perth, Australia, in October next year. The Group is also expected to consult extensively with governments, civil society groups and professional associations, and individuals within the Commonwealth as well as those beyond the membership with an interest in the Group’s work.

Sir Ronald is well known in the Caribbean and the United Kingdom, having served in the private sector on the Board of Directors of media, telecommunications, banking and sustainable forestry companies in Antigua and Barbuda, Belize, Barbados and Guyana. He was High Commissioner for Antigua and Barbuda to the United Kingdom between 1984 and 1987 and from 1996 to 2004.

Ms Francis is attached to the International Trade Centre as Executive Director. During her tenure at the ITC she has implemented a change management strategy to build common values and strengthen key management functions. (Caribnet)

CARICOM leaders to review governance structures

Thursday, July 8th, 2010
 
MONTEGO BAY, Jamaica (JIS) – Leaders have decided to have an urgent review of the governance structures of the Caribbean Community (CARICOM), as they seek to address frustrations regarding the pace of the implementation of decisions taken at regional summits.

Governance structure has been a major talking point at the 31st Regular Meeting of the Conference of Heads of CARICOM, in its final day in Montego Bay, Jamaica.

Speaking to the regional press media on Wednesday, Prime Minister of St Kitts and Nevis, Dr Denzil Douglas, said Heads of Government received a report from the Community Council of Ministers requesting a review of the institutions of CARICOM, and are of the view that such a step is urgently needed.

“We have basically agreed for a body of people to come together, hopefully the Ministers of Foreign Affairs, do a quick assessment based on what they have sent to us as a recommendation and see how far we can get in determining what model to go forward with,” Douglas said.

A concern expressed by several Heads, including Douglas and President of Guyana, Bharrat Jagdeo, is that there is no body with enough power to implement the decisions made by the leaders.

“If we were to have this permanent structure, that will continue to work, whether you have a change in government or not, the work continues,” Douglas argued.

He said the body would be empowered to pursue the work of CARICOM on a daily basis with regard to implementing decisions, only consulting the Heads on final decisions for immediate implementation.

He said the Heads of Government have agreed to examine the governance structures of other regional groups such as the Organization of American States, the European Union, and the Organization of Eastern Caribbean States, to see whether any aspects of these can be adopted by CARICOM.

Guyana’s president believes free movement of people critical to single economy

Thursday, July 8th, 2010
 
GEORGETOWN, Guyana (GINA) – Guyana’s President Bharrat Jagdeo said the free movement of people is a key element of a single economy of the region and believes that those who are eligible to travel should be allowed to do so freely.

Speaking at a press conference on Tuesday in Montego Bay, Jamaica, he said, “I don’t think we could move to a single economy without dealing with this issue. We have seen major improvements in the last several months.”

While he does not subscribe to Caribbean nationals travelling to other countries and breaking laws, President Jagdeo condemns what he described as, “inhumane, discriminatory treatment meted out by “tin Gods” at some airports”, referring to immigration officials at some ports of entry who act in authoritative ways toward citizens of other Caribbean Community (CARICOM) sister-states.

The Guyanese Head of State, who is in Jamaica attending the 31st meeting of the Conference of Heads of Government of the Caribbean Community said there are cases where even wealthy people and university students visiting for vacation have been subjected to such misfortune entering some countries.

He said this is evidence that a sustained harassment campaign cannot be just about persons with questionable intent being denied entry. Jagdeo believes this continues because port authorities feel somehow assured that there will be political coverage if such incidents continue.

He assured that immigration officials in Guyana will never engage in such practices.

“I will never allow them to do that. In fact we (the heads) spoke about allowing the Haitian businessmen to enter Caribbean countries freely, and I said from next week Monday I will initiate it. I will leave this meeting and get home and get it done and my immigration officials will respect that,” the President said.

He said Guyana has already implemented the six-month rule where any CARICOM national entering Guyana is automatically stamped in for six months.

Jagdeo said many immigrants enter countries to work and help to develop those states, earn and return home. He reminded that Guyana supports the Regional Travel Card System CARIPASS.

He said he hopes that it will solve the issue of Caribbean citizens being made to check with and interviewed by immigration officials at regional ports of entry.

Quizzed on the implementation of legislation that mirrors the Sunset Legislation used during Cricket World Cup (CWC), the President said it was introduced mainly for people travelling to the Caribbean from extra-regional countries. (Caribnet)

Govt pulls plug on smelter

Thursday, July 8th, 2010

By Sue-Ann Wayow South Bureau

ENERGY Minister Carolyn Seepersad-Bachan confirmed yesterday Government had pulled the plug on the Alutrint aluminium smelter project at the La Brea Industrial Estate.

Speaking with members of the media, following a luncheon hosted by the Energy Chamber at Paria Suites in La Romaine yesterday, the minister said the People’s Partnership had no intention of continuing with the construction of the smelter plant.

Construction stalled last June after High Court Justice Mira Dean-Armorer ordered an injunction, based on a challenge from several environmental organisations, against the decision by the Environmental Management Authority (EMA) to grant a Certificate of Environmental Clearance (CEC) to Alutrint. The order was appealed and a judgment is pending.

In the meantime, work on a port facility and power plant, both in support of the smelter, has continued in La Brea.

Seepersad-Bachan’s People’s Partnership Government had promised during the general election campaign there would be no smelter.

Yesterday, she said: “As of May 24, all further construction…stopped.”

She said no jobs would be lost, and alternative measures would be put in place to accommodate any incurred losses.

She did not outline the measures or how soon they would be implemented.

Environmentalist and anti-smelter activist Dr Wayne Kublalsingh has welcomed the move.

“It was the logical and scientific thing to do,” he said yesterday.

He said there was enough time to look at and evaluate the facts concerning the smelter plants to realise it was not beneficial to this country’s economy.

He said the construction of smelter plants was not only uneconomical, but it was also an ecological disaster for the south peninsula, and it significantly impacted on human health.

Kublalsingh said there should be other ways in which the port at Labidco and the power plant at the Union Industrial Estate could be utilised. He also suggested the 5,000-plus workers involved in previous operations be transferred to these facilities. (Trinidad Express)

Warner: Independents will pay political price

Thursday, July 8th, 2010

By —Camille Bethel

United National Congress (UNC) party chairman Jack Warner is preparing a report to submit to Prime Minister Kamla Persad-Bissessar when she returns from Jamaica–detailing the activities of two senior UNC politicians who encouraged rejected party candidates to run as independents in the July 26 Local Government election.

Warner first spoke about taking the senior officials before the party’s disciplinary committee during a meeting at Rienzi Complex, Couva, on Tuesday night, which the election candidates and rejected nominees were invited to.

Warner, who is acting as Prime Minister in the absence of Persad-Bissessar, said at the meeting that the six “UNC” nominees who filed as independents would pay with political price for their actions.

Yesterday, Warner told reporters he wanted people with the evidence of the internal meddling to bring the evidence to him.

He said, “I don’t want to go into details. Mrs Persad-Bissessar will be back next week and she would be given a full report.

“I don’t know all the evidence and I ask those who have the evidence to put it in writing, but I don’t have all the facts.”

Warner said despite some “ups and downs”, the People’s Partnership is intact.

He said 611 persons were interviewed for the Local Government elections and on Tuesday, 400 people came out to the meeting “to say thank you”.

“This only shows that the people want to participate and work,” Warner said. (Trinidad Express)

Jack doesn’t scare me!

Thursday, July 8th, 2010

By Camille Bethel camille.bethel@trinidadexpress.com

Independent candidate Rajendra Gosine, who was rejected by the screening committee of his party, the United National Congress (UNC), said yesterday he was not intimidated by the threats of disciplinary action made by Acting Prime Minister Jack Warner.

On Tuesday, Warner met with rejected candidates at Rienzi Complex, Couva, where he denounced the actions of six rejected UNC candidates who filed nomination papers as independents.

Warner said he was told the “UNC” independents acted on the advice of two senior UNC officials, one a Member of Parliament.

Yesterday, however, Gosine said he was never encouraged by any MP to file as an independent, but by the people.

In fact, he said the MP in his area, Rudranath Indarsingh, “tried to talk me out of it up to Tuesday, but I told him no I would be disappointing the people if I stepped down”.

Gosine planned to launch his campaign to contest the California /Point Lisas seat at Dow Village California last evening.

He said, “I will not be intimidated by anyone. I am going full throttle ahead with it because I believe that I must finish what I have started. It does not matter who said what, I have a commitment to the people who I represent.”

Gosine said for the past 12 years he has been serving the people on the sidelines, after being rejected by the party on several occasions in his bid to be the elected representative.

“Ninety-five per cent of the people in the area are disenchanted with the (UNC) party’s choice.

“They feel their intelligence has been insulted,” Gosine said. (Trinidad Express)

PM will deny request for leave

Thursday, July 8th, 2010

By
Carolyn Kissoon
South Bureau

Prime Minister Kamla Persad-Bissessar last night said she would
deny a request from acting Prime Minister and Minister of Works and
Transport, Jack Warner, seeking leave to attend the finals of the 2010
World Cup in South Africa.

Speaking to the Express from Jamaica, where she is attending the
Caricom Heads of Government meeting, Persad-Bissessar said she had not
been contacted by Warner with such a request.

However, she said she would not be able to allow it, since she is
not scheduled to return home until Monday and would be in no position
to find a replacement to forward to President George Maxwell Richards.

Warner had made his intention to apply for a leave of absence to
travel to South Africa for Sunday’s final, between the Netherlands and
Spain, during a ceremony to begin road works along Papourie Road,
Barrackpore, which was held at the Inverness Presbyterian School. (See
Page 8)

“I have not seen a single match since I returned from the
opening. But I am hoping that I find a house or a parlour somewhere to
watch today’s match (between Germany and Spain). And if I my application
was granted, I would be going to back Spain,” he said before
yesterday’s semi-final between Spain and Germany, which the former won
1-0.

During his absence on FIFA business, Opposition Leader Dr Keith
Rowley requested an investigation into Warner keeping both his position
as vice president of FIFA and his ministerial post.

Legal opinions from several legal experts, however, found no
clear conflict of interest between the two jobs. (Trinidad Express)

—Reporting by Andy Johnson

MAX IN ABOUT-TURN

Thursday, July 8th, 2010

By Ria Taitt Political Editor

President George Maxwell Richards’ change of heart on the nominees to the Police Service Commission (PSC) has been welcomed by the Government. It has, however, caused serious concern with Opposition Leader Dr Keith Rowley, who yesterday spoke directly to Richards about his reservations. Rowley has also formally written to the President on the matter.

Yesterday, the President recalled a notification sent on June 25 to the House of Representatives, seeking its approval for the appointment of Christopher Thomas, Seunath Jairam, Jeewan Singh, Kenneth Parker and Jacqueline Cheeseman to the PSC. The President replaced this with a new notification, which proposed the appointment of former House speaker Nizam Mohammed, former Industrial Court judge Addison Khan, attorney Martin George, Kenneth Parker and Jacqueline Cheeseman.

Yesterday, Acting Prime Minister Jack Warner confirmed Government had submitted the names of persons to form the Police Service Commission to the President. The Government’s list included Mohammed, George, Khan and Cheeseman.

Under the Constitution Amendment Act, the President shall (must), after consultation with the Prime Minister and Leader of the Opposition, nominate persons who are qualified and experienced in the disciplines of law, finance, sociology or management to be appointed as members of the PSC. The President shall then issue a notification in respect of each person nominated, and it shall be subject to affirmative resolution (approval or rejection) of the House of Representatives. The President may, in his own discretion, appoint a chairman from among these members.

Informed sources yesterday said when the President sent the first notification to Parliament, the consultation between the President and the Prime Minister “had not yet ended, so it was really a bit premature”.

“The (original) names did not reflect the consultation between the Prime Minister and the President, so the process (of consultation) was restarted, and the President reopened the consultation process,” the source said.

It was after the completion of the consultation process the President recalled the original notification, proposing a new list reflecting the names proposed by the Government. Sources said it would be pointless for the President to “force on the House names which the majority in the House has already indicated to him they would not support. And so, he said to the Government, “Let’s talk again,” the source added.

“He entered into a negotiation process with the Prime Minister,” the source stated.

However, reliable sources said Rowley was not consulted in this new negotiation process. The names of Mohammed, George and Khan (proposed in the second notification) formed no part of the President’s consultation with Rowley, sources said, adding the Opposition Leader was not even aware the first notification was being substituted.

Contacted yesterday, all Rowley was prepared to say was: “The new list came to my attention from the Parliament this afternoon, and I was sufficiently concerned that I immediately communicated with the President. I spoke to him and I have since written to him, asking him to reconsider, and drawing to his attention my concerns surrounding this particular development.”

It is understood that one name, Parker (who survived both notifications), was recommended by Rowley.

The term of office of the PSC expired on June 30. Government sources said yesterday that to say Mohammed would be chairing the PSC was “premature” since that matter was entirely up to the President.

Sources said the President had the right to change his mind with respect to any notification, once it has not been formally laid in the House. The first notification was not laid. It was only given to Prime Minister Kamla Persad-Bissessar, Government Leader Roodal Moonilal, Opposition Leader Rowley and Chief Whip Marlene McDonald…(Trinidad Express)

Big money but big risk

Thursday, July 8th, 2010

 

Livern Barrett, Gleaner Writer

The cost of Super Lotto tickets and the daunting reality that the game has not had a winner since its August 2009 start have pushed some lottery players to stick to the more popular Cash Pot.

Even with the chance to win a life-changing jackpot of $413 million, some lottery patrons contend that in the current economic climate, ticket prices of $150 and $250 are not worth the risk.

“Let’s say you play it two times fi the week, that’s $500. Next week, you try again, nuh $1,000 that you gone. Check up dat fi di month an’ see,” said Sophia McGregor, a mother of four who lives in the Corporate Area.

Better use of funds

“A better me use da money deh an’ pay fi me pickney dem school,” she said, adding that she has a daughter who is preparing for exams next year.

Another woman, who spoke on condition of anonymity, was even more cynical, questioning “why me a go spend $250 and me naw win nutten. Plus, me never see nobody win.”

“The money (jackpot) look nuff, but da game deh set a way … . It look like dem do it fi ketch people money,” she lamented.

The staggering multimillion-dollar jackpot is still available going into Friday night’s draw.

The game was introduced by Supreme Ventures Limited (SVL) on August 25 last year with a starter jackpot of $180 million.

The jackpot is increased based on sales each time there is no winner.

SVL officials would not respond to queries about Super Lotto ticket sales, but The Gleaner understands that the company is planning to introduce changes that will give players a better chance of winning.

From the outset, SVL had warned that the odds of winning the Super Lotto would be far greater than other games because it is played in seven other Caribbean countries.

In contrast, some lotto players said the Cash Pot game was cheaper and easier to win.

In fact, Douglas admitted that she has won several times.

“At least wid di Cash Pot you can spend $10 an’ you stand a chance fi get back something,” she reasoned.

“But wid the Super Lotto, it too dear and you nuh win nutten.” (Jamaica Gleaner)

livern.barrett@gleanerjm.com