WHY THE PRIMARY HOMES FAILED
Monday, October 19th, 2009DAILY NATION
OCTOBER 16, 2009
A major programme launched by the last Barbados Labour party (BLP) administration just over five years ago to provide 300 low-income houses failed because of four main factors, the Audit Office has found.
In a “Special Report” on the National Housing Corporation (NHC), the Audit Office said the factors included:
(a) Failure to vest some of the areas in the NHC, which meant lots could not be sold to applicants;
(b) Delays in meeting conditions set by the Town and Country Planning Department;
(c) Delays in obtaining financing to carry out infrastructural work; and
(d) Refusal of contractors to build houses at prices which were over three years old.
The Primary Homes Programme was launched on September 1, 2004 to provide quality, affordable homes to low-income earners. Since then, 67 houses were built and by March 31, 2008, a further 43 were constructed for individuals on their own land.
The then Government had identified ten areas for the development and construction of 303 houses: Arlie Heights, St. Michael (16); Lower Burney, St. Michael (20); French Village, St. Peter (15); four Hill, St. Peter (40); Greens, St. George (49); Constant, St. George (55); Work Hall, St. Philip (40); Marchfield, St. Philip (33); Mount Poyer, St. Lucy (18); and St. Ann’s, St. Joseph (17).
Obtain a house
The types of house identified ranged in price from $42 000 to $100 000 and the income of qualifiers could not exceed $694 weekly or $3 000 per month. Another component was to assist people who owned land to obtain a timber or wall house. The audit report noted that on February 24, 2004, several contractors had signed up to work in the programme, but four years later, by March 2008, some of them had dropped out “because they claimed the price being offered to build houses was inadequate”.
It said permission has been granted for infrastructural work at Work Hall in October 2006, provided certain conditions were met before work began, but they were not, and the Chief Town Planner on June 19, 2007, ordered a cessation of that project.
Permission was subsequently granted and at the date of the report (August 2009), some houses were under construction. A contract was awarded in January 2007 for infrastructural work in Four Hill, St. Peter and work was started by the contractor before planning permission was granted, and the Chief Town Planner again ordered a cessation.
It was on January 15, 2007, the report said, that permission was granted for sub-division of land into lots for houses at the site. The report said a lack of financing in the initial stages meant the NHC could not do the infrastructural work in the various areas and it was not until 2007 that it was able to get $7.3 million to finance the programme.
After four years, the report added, very little house construction had taken place, except for Arlie Heights and Lower Burney. (AB)
P.S. DENIS KELLMAN, M.P. HAD PREVIOUS VOICED HIS CONCERN ON THE ABOVE SITUATION… READ HIS VIEWS BELOW.
BARBADOS ADVOCATE – DENIS KELLMAN’S COLUMN – THE DEBATE
JANUARY 14, 2005
FORGET FRIENDS, LET FAIRNESS PREVAIL
Recently, I was asked whether I would appoint any former ministers of government who are contractors on any boards that would create conflicts of interest. I readily replied that it is wrong for a man to be a contractor and stop himself from getting work. The system must protect persons from themselves and wherever the possibility of interest is possible, such persons must not be placed on boards.
In recent times, as I traversed Barbados, I am hearing about contractors who all of a sudden are working for Government agencies and who are not bidding for work, yet are getting work. Theses contractors are using the power in these organizations to get permission for professionals to act opposite to their training.
The directors of these organizations must be protected from political appointees, who are only thinking pocket and who do not care whether a house that should be repaired for $28 000, has a final cost of $60 000.
Further, every costing that is submitted by such persons who have power in their corner is varied upwards and the boys looked after.
Mr. Prime Minister, you need to give certain section of ministries to Ministers who are accountable to the public. The masses that include the poor and elderly should be protected from these persons who feel that they are only accountable to elected persons.
These persons are not treating the elderly fairly, when money extracted is now delivering only half of what the woody fellow would have delivered. I know that you are going to summon Mr. Upright to your office, and you are going to investigate these persons who are not giving the elderly their fair return.
There is no wrong in our brothers and sisters getting work or privileges, but these men must appreciate the confidence placed in them and set about to increase the popularity of the party, instead of robbing the masses by extracting excessively and having Ministers who are normally regarded as professionals, being branded wrongly.
I have said previously that those “social heads” should be prorated and the amounts known to each Member of Parliament, so that these heads could easily be monitored by the Member of Parliament, in order that their inconsistencies can be easily highlighted.
Members of Parliament should ensure that work for the elderly is carried out without accommodating their friends and be prepared to distance themselves from persons seeking to gouge them. Selfishness and greed cannot be a positive factor when considering members for boards. These members are prepared to bribe and belittle their brothers and sisters to satisfy their own personal greed.
I do not want the elderly telling me anymore that money was voted to repair their homes and it was expended without any of the m receiving aid. Estimates in the future must show the number of houses to be built and the price per house. Parliament should then be informed as to whether these goals were realized.
Social engineers need to deal with the masses and the rich in this country. We must understand that this country is made up of the rich and masses, and not the rich, middle class and the poor. Nobody wants to be labeled poor and we as writers and politicians should appreciate this point. Being poor should be seen as a negative, but being “born poor should be seen as a positive.”
When I was a boy, I heard about lining and it referred to ground and clothing, but these days it seems to mean lining your pocket with money off the backs of the masses.
The Minister of Agriculture would do good to get board members to go and learn the trade of farming or tailoring, seeing that I will always be a “rural man”. Are we aware that a price increase in water rates can be more damaging than a price increase in oil?
(Denis Kellman is the Member of Parliament for St. Lucy, Barbados)
News of this came from Minister of Finance and the Economy, Harold Lovell, at a press conference held at the ministry on Friday to update the public on the discussions thus far with the IMF delegation as it relates to the country’s fiscal consolidation.



