St. Lucia Star
Written By: Toni Nicholas

Minister for Home Affairs Guy Mayers says the government will come down hard on illegal immigrants.
Prime Minister Stephenson King proudly told regional journalists recently that Saint Lucia has had a “soft policy” when it comes to illegal immigrants and saw this as something CARICOM heads should adopt.It was his response to recent regional wrangling about Barbados’ immigration policy towards CARICOM nationals. However, at the end of a CARICOM amnesty here in Saint Lucia, Home Affairs and National Security Minister Guy Mayers says it is time to get tough.
The issue of CARICOM nationals living illegally in other regional territories has been a shouting match across the Caribbean seas ever since the Prime Minister of Barbados David Thompson made the statement that CARICOM nationals were “ever so welcome” but that they should “wait for a call” before seeking to live and work in Barbados.
The Vincentian Prime Minister Ralph Gonsalves blasted Thompson and Barbadian authorities for the treatment that some of his nationals had allegedly received in Bridgetown, adding that other nationals from Guyana and Jamaica were being targeted and treated unfairly. Guyana’s President Bharrat Jagdeo also expressed concerns about the treatment meted out to his nationals in Barbados, many of whom claim they have been roughed up by immigration authorities and deported.
Prime Minister King had this to say on the matter: “This is not the kind of environment that we would want to establish within a Caribbean Community. We have to continue to pursue the ideals of one Caribbean and we have got to get over those hurdles. We have a common purpose which is building a Caribbean nation. And we cannot at this stage begin to place doors at our ports of entry and begin to profile our nationals by saying “you are Guyanese, I am not going to allow you to come in,” said King adding that his Government had a “soft” policy on Caribbean non-nationals.
But whilst the debate over the Barbadian issue continues to make headlines, there are some who are questioning these very lax and soft policies which seem to be creating more problems for regional integration and are reportedly also having an impact on crime, national security, food and economic security.
A recent crackdown on non-nationals living in Barbados illegally led to the detention and removal of 47 non-nationals some with criminal records. Just this past June, during early morning raids in Castries to crackdown on criminal activity, several non-nationals living here illegally, some of them wanted by the police, were apprehended. To date there has been no further information from the police as to who those persons were or their country of origin, something the Home Affairs Minister told the STAR is a question of national security. He also added that having persons living here illegally and not regularising their status could put a strain on the economy.
Similar sentiments were expressed by the Barbadian leader during a press conference on Tuesday. However, David Thompson told reporters that even if insult was taken, none was intended by his government’s new immigration policy.
“While Barbados remains on board with the CSME process, we cannot commit ourselves to full and unfettered movement at this time and that this country’s social services are already feeling the strain,” he said.
“That was my position. It was not meant to be an insult, what it essentially means is that when the conditions are appropriate in Barbados and the resources are there for us to accommodate more Caribbean nationals beyond the categories that are already agreed, we will do so. But we’re not ready right now,” he informed reporters.
“We were ready at the last Heads to admit two new categories and if there are others over time they will be welcomed when we make that call at the level of Heads,” Thompson added.
“We’re not carrying out any campaign against anybody. People have until December to make themselves right and I urge them to do so,” said Thompson, who had earlier announced the amnesty which took effect at the start of June.
Thompson has also been quoted earlier as saying that more than his own pronouncement, those of other Caribbean leaders who have spoken out against him was what was hurting the regional integration process more than the policy itself. “There seems to be a mad rush now for everybody to say something new. I have announced a domestic immigration policy, that is not a matter for other Caribbean prime ministers to comment on,” Thompson said earlier this year.
“It is a sovereign matter which our Parliament and our policy directives base the objectives on,” he said.
On Wednesday the STAR contacted Lokesh Singh, the Saint Lucia Consul to Guyana to comment on how an amnesty for CARICOM nationals announced earlier this year, by this government had worked. In December of 2008, Home Affairs and National Security Minister Guy Mayers had announced a three-month amnesty which commenced January 1, 2009. Under the terms, applicants should not have possessed a criminal record, whether locally or externally and should not have been a deportee. Additionally applicants must have had resided continuously in Saint Lucia for a period of not less than three years.
According to Singh, his agency fully supported the amnesty and worked with the Home Affairs Minister and started having meetings with Guyanese nationals immediately.
“We agreed upon a formula which I believed worked smoothly and in the end we processed more than 500 Guyanese national,” Singh told the STAR.
Singh acknowledged that there were many other Caricom non-nationals living in Saint Lucia some of them illegally, but that it was only his association which had responded and reacted to the government’s amnesty with such urgency. Guy Mayers had announced that there were an estimated ten thousand Guyanese nationals forming part of the local population a figure Singh described as just about right. He added that many of them were children of Saint Lucians who had lived in Guyana. About the Barbados situation, Singh said that their policy which looked at persons living in Barbados for eight years disqualified a lot of people.
“The Saint Lucia model is the most humane and practical model which has good merit and is something I would recommend other Caricom territories look at this,” he says.
On Wednesday Guy Mayers told the STAR that there were some other non-nationals coming in on their own to regularise their stay.
“Those who have done that can now apply for citizenship or temporary stay, depending on their status and what they qualify for. We have also forgiven their debts,” Mayers told the STAR. He is also awaiting a report from the immigration department and a report from his PS which will be tabled before Cabinet.
“Those who have not done so and taken the amnesty for granted would have to leave. I am sorry but we cannot allow persons breaking the law, we will come down hard on those persons who essentially can become a strain on the economy,” Mayers says.
With several global and domestic issues to deal with, the perennial problem of illegal immigration is one which Saint Lucia and other CARICOM states have had to deal with. And sometimes foreign policies, politics and even insularity can make the issues even thornier than they really are, this one being no different.